VG+ These are incredibly time-consuming to grade as they are so susceptible to damage being a small step better than newsprint paper. The ones you see here, with the exception of the Collins, are among the nicest we've ever seen. With the highest PSA grade EVER received on ANY Butterfinger a 5, and they've only ever give two of those, I feel it's safe to say that there would be some top of the population examples in here and quite likely some new highest grades of ANY Butterfinger. Where you find smudges look for wrinkles or creases or just warps from being bent. near the smudge on front and the ones on back there is a ripple in the paper. Not traditionally what you think of as a crease but it is visible also light corner wear