While technically correct you are getting a LOT of card for the grade. With some heavier damage to the lower left corner and some light chipping to the bottom border the grade is correct. However you have a massive, crease-free image of Gehrig in his prime on a clean, hand-cut card that measures correctly and this is an opportunity you just don't get every day! For those of you unfamiliar with the issue these measure approximately 5" x 7"