Sometimes you get lucky. With light to slightly heavier corner wear and minor edge wear mainly on the back the "5" grade was a bit of a pleasant surprise. One of the most misidentified players in any set this is NOT Jimmy Collins the HOF'er (which would be weird considering he retired in 1908, nor is it Rip Collins who was a pitcher, mainly for Detroit who retired in 1931. This is Jim "Ripper" Collins who was an All-Star first baseman most notably for the Gashouse Gang Cardinals of the 1930's