Would you believe that people complained about the make up of All-Star Teams from the very first "All-Star" game? This paper includes the roster for the New York team as picked by the presidents of the New York clubs. The editorial comment at the end of the blurb is "We do not believe that the selection gives entire satisfaction."

As all the Porter's Spirit of the Times in the auction, this was stitched into a bound volume so there is extensive spine damage including the stitch holes. Paper is complete and easily legible with the baseball content appearing inside on pages 4 and 5.